I
think we can all agree that the story of the Metamorphosis has very little chance of happening in real life. Unless
quantum mechanics goes berserk, none of us will probably ever have to worry about
waking up and realizing that we have metamorphosed into some kind of despicable
vermin – insectoid or otherwise. What makes this novella unique, however, is
that once we accept the premise that Gregor Samsa has turned into a “monstrous
insect,” the rest of the story follows quite logically and realistically. In
fact, Gregor’s experiences after his metamorphosis felt oddly familiar to me, as
if I had heard such stories before. It took me a while to figure out why, until
recently I realized that I had read many stories like this throughout my
academic career, each one slightly varied, but always along the same lines.
Gregor’s life as an insect is uncannily similar to the lives of people in
minority groups in our inherently prejudiced culture.
The
parallels begin on the very morning that he mutates. As he tries to get out of
bed, he does not seem to think that being an insect will hinder his ability to be
a travelling salesman at all – the fact that his appearance is not like anyone
else’s does not mean that his mind and personality are any different. When
other people see him, however, even his parents, they are repulsed. All they
see is what he looks like on the outside, someone different and untrustworthy –
someone who they should leave alone and not mix with. The next incident occurs a
few hours or so later. For the first time in five years, he is a little bit
late to get to work, and immediately the chief clerk comes knocking at the
door, asking what is wrong with him. One would think that out of all the
employees at the firm, there would be at least a few who were late, and who
would have worse track records than Gregor, and yet it is the chief clerk himself
who comes to check on him. Why? Even though he has been one of the most
faithful workers at the firm, his employers don’t trust him solely because he works
for a purpose different from everyone else’s – to repay his father’s debt. As
the story goes on, such incidents continue to occur, with his father throwing
apples at him, his sister not caring enough to give him the food he wants, and
finally with the three lodgers who refuse to pay the Samsas when they discover that
they had been living alongside Gregor.
By this
point, Gregor, being of very practical disposition, had mostly accepted the
effect his appearance had on others, but as with everyone who has to endure such
callous and unwarranted torment, it took a toll on him, and he became
depressed. The sheer savage power of racism had caused him to be so shamed and mistreated
that eventually, the man who had once worked incessantly and tirelessly to
support his entire family was broken, and he had no energy left to do anything
but lay down and die.
I think this is an interesting idea, since as you said there does seem to be some parallels between the ways Gregor is treated and some minorities have been treated. One thing that I feel supports this theory is that Gregor isn't just left isolated, but the family and everyone else doesn't even entertain the thought that he might still understand human speech. They assume he is hopelessly inferior in a way that is somewhat similar to a group of people assuming another group of people to be inferior based on their appearance. Even when the family tries to treat Gregor nicely, it is always in the context of how a bug would like to be treated, not how Gregor would want to be treated if he was still capable of human thoughts.
ReplyDeleteVery cool idea here. I completely agree, you could definitely tie the way Gregor is treated to the way minorities are treated based on appearance. Going beyond race, people who defy the gender binary, people with physical disabilities, people whose body types do not fit a certain constructed image of beauty, etc, are too often treated a particular (biased) way only because of how they look. There's a sense of other, but not in a "you're an other and you're BETTER" way, but a sense of other that implies that person is somehow inferior. Sushrut put it really well -- the idea that because someone looks a certain way, they are thought to be different in their sense of humanity. I think race is definitely a big "other" in our society (unfortunately). It's cool to tie this idea to The Metamorphosis, and I hadn't thought about it in that way before. Nice observation!
ReplyDeleteWhen you introduce the idea of racism as generating Kafkaesque predicaments for those who suffer it, the first thing I think of is Ralph Ellison's _Invisible Man_, which is full of "Kafkaesque" moments where realistic elements from American cultural history take on a nightmarish but also grotesquely comic dimension, with the protagonist undaunted and eager to please.
ReplyDeleteThis thought makes a lot of sense to me. It fits very well with how Gregor does absolutely everything in his power to please other people, and yet no one is ever grateful for what he does. On the contrary, all of the other characters do little other than abuse him, making him progressively more inferior until the best thing for him to do is die. Nice observation, I hadn't thought along these lines at all!
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate the comparison you have made here. I think that the points you have made are extremely realistic. Especially when it comes to Gregor's rejection of his self. There's actually a term for his thoughts, internalized oppression. He starts to believe that he is actually what everyone thinks he is, that is, inferior, a burden, a nuisance. Incredibly sad thought. But one I am extremely glad you made because the parallels can be very clearly seen.
ReplyDelete